First year recruiting classes for University of Arkansas football coaches since the inception of recruiting services have had their own unique challenges.
Former coach Bobby Petrino inherited the best situation when he arrived in Fayetteville after Houston Nutt’s 10-year run and 75-48 record that included the 50-48 triple-overtime victory at LSU that ended Nutt’s tenure.
National recruiting analyst Tom Lemming hosts The Lemming Report on CBS Sports Network and Nutt is one of his co-hosts.
“Houston knew Arkansas and he did a good job of recruiting, I’m not saying that because he’s one of my co-hosts, but overall he did a terrific job,” Lemming said.
Petrino’s first class in 2008 averaged out as the 26th best class in the nation. Rivals rated the class No. 36 while 247 had the class 25th best, ESPN had it at No. 18 while Lemming rated the class No. 26 nationally.
Central Arkansas Christian athlete Joe Adams was ESPN’s highest rated prospect in the class. He was the No. 41 recruit nationally while Camden Fairview running back De’Anthony Curtis came in at No. 76. Quarterback Tyler Wilson of Greenwood was listed as the No. 81 prospect in the nation. Athlete Jerico Nelson of Destrehan, La., was the fourth prospect in the class to receive a grade of 80 or more which now translates to being a four-star prospect.
The Hogs inked 12 more in-state prospects in the class including receivers Jarius Wright, Greg Childs and Chris Gragg of Warren. Former Arkansas assistant and recruiting coordinator Tim Horton is credited with keeping the in-state class intact during the two and a half weeks before Petrino was hired.
“Tim was an outstanding recruiter,” said Lemming, who’s been covering national recruiting since 1978. “He’s the guy that should’ve never left Arkansas. He was like Mr. Arkansas. He did a great job. He always did a tremendous job of promoting the school too. If you look back all the years I’ve been doing this, Tim has to be ranked as one of the best recruiters in Arkansas history.”
Fresh off a 5-7 record in his first year, Petrino signed what is considered the best class since recruiting services started in the early 2000s.
The 2009 class averaged out as the No. 17 class in the nation with Rivals ranking it No. 16, 247 and ESPN having the class at No. 20 and Lemming rating the class at No. 15.
In-state cornerback Darius Winston of Helena-West Helena was the headliner of the class. ESPN rated him the No. 3 cornerback and No. 25 overall prospect in the nation. Tulsa East Central David Gordon was rated the No. 12 cornerback nationally. ESPN rated Knile Davis of Missouri City, (Texas) Marshall the No. 20 running back in the nation.
The class also included future NFL players Travis Swanson, Cobi Hamilton, Ronnie Wingo Jr. and Robert Thomas.
“It was a very athletic class that filled all their needs and they turned out to be some of the best athletes at Arkansas in recent history,” Lemming said.
Petrino was fired in the spring of 2012 after having a 34-17 record in four seasons and was replaced by John L. Smith, who led the Hogs to a 4-8 record before being fired. Bret Bielema, who was hired away from Wisconsin, signed a class that averaged No. 26 nationally in 2013.
The class was rated No. 27 by Rivals while 247 rated the class No. 23 and ESPN No. 31. Lemming rated the class No. 24 nationally.
ESPN rated five signees in the 2014 class as four-star prospects with running back Alex Collins of Plantation, (Fla.) South Plantation and Pulaski Academy tight end Hunter Henry headlining the class. Collins was the No. 7 running back and No. 57 overall recruit in the nation while Henry was the No. 2 tight end and No. 69 prospect in the nation
“When he was at Wisconsin he did an outstanding job recruiting the state and skill position players who can fit into his program,” Lemming said. “He brought that same recruiting mentality to Arkansas. He did a very good job the first couple of years.”
Bielema’s second class averaged out as the No. 29 class nationally with Rivals and 247 having it as the No. 29, ESPN No. 30 and Tom Lemming No. 29. Lemming believes Bielema was surprised by the dog eat dog mentality of the SEC in recruiting.
“Super aggressive and non-stop, you couldn’t catch your breath,” said Lemming of the SEC. “Recruiting was 24/7. In the Big 10 it was seasonal. You always recruited, but not to the aggressiveness they did in the SEC back then.”
Petrino and Bielema didn’t have to deal with the December early signing period like former coach Chad Morris and coach Sam Pittman did. Morris was hired on Dec. 6 and 14 days latter the early signing period started on Dec. 20 and ended two days later.
Rivals rated the Morris’ first class in 2018 the No. 61 nationally, while 247 and ESPN had the class at No. 45 and No. 51 for an average of 52 nationally. The class didn’t make the cut for Lemming’s top 25.
Morris and his staff came back strong the next year with a class that averaged No. 21 in the country. Rivals had the class at No. 20, 247 at No. 23, ESPN at No. 23 while Lemming rated it as the 19th best.
The class featured 10 ESPN four-star prospects including Pulaski Academy tight end Hudson Henry, Warren receiver Treylon Burks, cornerback Devin Bush of New Orleans Edna Karr, receiver Trey Knox of Murfreesboro, (Tenn.) Blackmon and safety Jalen Catalon of Mansfield, (Texas) Legacy.
After Morris’ second class, Lemming thought the Hogs were headed in the right direction.
“I just thought he did a terrific job in Texas and he had a lot of connections,” Lemming said. “To me at the time, I really thought Arkansas was zooming up there, but things were falling apart on the field, but recruiting wise I think he would’ve continued doing well.”
Pittman and his staff pulled off one of the more surprising recruiting classes in the nation for the 2020 class. The class averaged out to be the No. 31 class nationally with it being listed as the No. 41 by Rivals, No. 30 by 247, No. 29 by ESPN and No. 26 by Lemming.
Pittman, who was hired on Dec. 8, inked nine prospects during the Dec. 18-20 early signing period. ESPN rated five prospects in the class four-star prospects and featured Memphis Central athlete Darin Turner, the No. 18 receiver in the nation, Memphis University School’s Marcus Henderson, the No. 6 offensive guard in the nation along with the No. 15 cornerback in the nation Myles Slusher of Broken Arrow, Oklahoma.
Malik Hornsby of Missouri City, (Texas) Marshall was rated the No. 9 dual-threat quarterback and Hazen’s Blayne Toll was the No. 19 athlete in the nation.
Pittman had to recruit after one of the worst periods of Arkansas football that saw the Razorbacks go 4-8, 2-10 and 2-10 the past three seasons.
“It comes down to the ability of the head coach to convince the recruits his program is the one that’s going to be the one moving up and get it to be one of the top teams in the conference,” Lemming said. “It’s more perception that it is reality sometimes in recruiting. If the perception is the program is moving north than you’re gong to do well in recruiting. If it’s stuck in the perception you’re stuck in the middle or going south, you’re not going to do well.”
Having SEC success in recruiting and on the field bodes well for Pittman’s second class and beyond.
“Wherever he’s been he’s had a good reputation as a recruiter so he brings experience as a recruiter and success also and success at big schools,” Lemming said. “It’s not a big surprise that he finished well. I look for him to do even better.”