Photo credit: Larry Singer. Richard Smith rests on a grassy area near the intersection of Washington and East Cedar in El Dorado.
By Larry Singer
For Between Editions
On Wednesday, April 24, a photograph I took appeared at the top of the front page of the El Dorado News-Times. It featured an El Dorado police officer, Andrew Russell, checking on the welfare of a homeless man, Richard Smith, who was resting on the grass at the intersection of Washington and East Center.
The next day a letter from one of our readers, who was critical of the photo, appeared on the editorial page.
The reader felt that the photograph was inappropriate.
I am both grateful and honored that this reader (a) looked at the picture, (b) thought about the picture quite a bit and (c) was so affected she actually sat down and wrote my editor a letter about the picture.
I don’t agree that the picture was unsuitable or improper for several reasons.
As a photojournalist, I believe my job is to tell stories with photographs, and this picture really did tell a story.
While, at first glance, the image seems to show a police officer harassing a homeless person, nothing, as the caption explains, could be farther from the truth.
I had no idea Richard Smith was at the intersection until someone, who did not identify himself, called me and said a photographer from the paper really needed to capture Mr. Smith on film.
Shortly after I arrived, Officer Russell pulled up in his police cruiser, got out and, to my surprise, the first words out of his mouth were, “Hi Richard, how are you doing today?”
After a brief conversation, during which Officer Russell determined that Mr. Smith, who has chronic, long term physical medical problems, did not require transport to a medical facility, he told Smith to try and take care of himself and drove off to serve and protect elsewhere.
That was the story.
A kind, caring police officer took the time to care about someone who some might say has fallen between the cracks.
When I asked Richard Smith if he had any problems with his picture being in the paper, he said he did not.
While seeing a man laying in the grass on a rainy day may make some people uncomfortable, I believe the kindness shown by one human being to another far outweighs any possible discomfort some readers may feel about the plight of the homeless.
Pictures of the homeless are never fun to look at, but in this case, they can be really worthwhile.
Larry Singer is a photographer for the El Dorado News-Times.